VerdictWorld.com
Everett Conant III: the 2011 Wheatland shootings and life sentences

Everett Conant III: the 2011 Wheatland shootings and life sentences

By LifespanSoftware · November 19, 2026

Everett Conant III, then aged 37, was sentenced on Tuesday 12 November 2013 to five consecutive life terms, four of them without the possibility of parole. District Judge John Brooks passed the sentences in Platte County, Wyoming. They related to a shooting on 7 July 2011 in the town of Wheatland, in which Conant's three sons and his brother were killed and his then-wife was wounded. This article sets out how the case progressed through the courts.

The shootings in Wheatland

Wheatland is a small agricultural town about 70 miles north of Cheyenne. On the evening of Thursday 7 July 2011, shots were fired inside the family's mobile home on Oak Street. Four people died: Conant's sons, aged 11, 13 and 18, and his brother, aged 33. Conant's then-wife was shot and wounded but managed to escape the home.

Reports at the time said Conant surrendered without incident. The killings shocked the community, and a vigil was held in the days that followed.

Charges and early hearings

Conant appeared in court the day after the shootings. He was charged with first-degree murder, attempted first-degree murder, battery and a weapons offence. Under Wyoming law, the murder and attempted murder charges carried a possible sentence of death or life imprisonment without parole.

Proceedings were then put on hold while Conant underwent a mental evaluation at the state hospital in Evanston. In November 2011, Circuit Judge Randal Arp ruled at a preliminary hearing that the prosecution's case was strong enough for Conant to stand trial on four counts of murder in the District Court. Conant's lawyers said they did not dispute that he was competent to face the charges. In plain terms, that meant he was judged able to understand the proceedings and to take part in his own defence.

What a preliminary hearing does

A preliminary hearing in a lower court is not a trial. The judge decides only whether the evidence is enough to send the case to a higher court. It does not decide guilt.

The no contest pleas

In June 2013, Conant pleaded no contest to four counts of first-degree murder. He also pleaded no contest to one count of attempted first-degree murder, relating to the shooting of his then-wife.

A no contest plea means a defendant does not dispute the charges and accepts conviction, but does not formally say "guilty". The court then enters a conviction and moves to sentencing. Because Conant pleaded, there was no jury trial and no verdict to be delivered. The central question was the sentence.

Sentencing in November 2013

The sentencing hearing turned on mental illness. Conant's lawyers accepted that he deserved punishment. They asked the judge to impose a single life sentence with the chance of eventual parole. They argued that he had been mentally ill when he opened fire, and said he had become a different man after treatment at the Wyoming State Hospital. Reports of the hearing said there was agreement that Conant had a mental illness.

Prosecutor Eric Jones asked for the maximum: five consecutive life sentences without parole. He argued that no mental illness justifies taking another person's life. A statement from the boys' mother, who had since divorced Conant, was read to the court by the prosecutor.

Judge Brooks rejected the defence request. He said each victim deserved to be recognised by a separate sentence. He imposed five consecutive life terms, one for each of the four killings and one for the attempted murder. Four of the five were without parole.

What the sentences mean

The word "consecutive" is important. Consecutive sentences are served one after another, not at the same time. Four of the terms were life without parole, so Conant has no prospect of release under them. The fifth life term, for the attempted murder, was the only one that allowed parole.

The judge's reasoning, as reported, also shows how courts treat mental illness at sentencing. Evidence of illness can be put forward in mitigation, meaning as a reason for a lighter sentence. The judge is not bound to accept it, and here it did not displace the sentences the prosecution sought.

The community response

Local reporting after the sentencing described it as a step towards healing for Wheatland. Many residents said the case had weighed on the town since 2011. The police chief attended the hearing and sat at the back of the courtroom.

Summary of the case

  • Date of offences: 7 July 2011, Wheatland, Wyoming.
  • Deaths: four, comprising three sons and a brother. One person was wounded.
  • Pleas: no contest to four counts of first-degree murder and one count of attempted first-degree murder, entered in June 2013.
  • Sentence: five consecutive life terms, four without parole, imposed on 12 November 2013 by District Judge John Brooks.

Closing note

The case of Everett Conant III shows a common route through the US courts. It began with a rapid arrest and charge. A mental evaluation and a competency finding followed, and then pleas of no contest and a contested sentencing hearing. A judge, not a jury, decided the sentence after weighing a defence argument based on mental health against a prosecution call for the maximum penalty. The result was the harshest outcome available short of the death penalty.