Robert Black: child murders 1981–1986, trials and convictions
Robert Black, a Scottish delivery driver, was convicted at Newcastle Crown Court on 19 May 1994 of the kidnap and murder of three girls. A court in Northern Ireland later convicted him of a fourth murder, committed in 1981. He died in prison in January 2016, aged 68. The murders took place between 1981 and 1986, and the girls were aged between 5 and 11. The hunt for him became one of the largest murder investigations in British history.
Who Robert Black was
Black was born in Grangemouth, Stirlingshire, on 21 April 1947. His mother did not keep him, and he was brought up by foster carers in Kinlochleven and later in children's homes. He came to official attention as a teenager. In 1963 he was arrested after an assault on a young girl in Greenock and was admonished, which in Scots law is a formal warning rather than a sentence. He later had a further conviction for a similar offence.
As an adult he worked as a van driver for a London poster distribution company. The job took him regularly across England, Scotland and, by ferry, Northern Ireland. That mobility became central to the case, because the crimes were spread across several police force areas and for years were not linked.
The four murders
The four girls whose murders led to his convictions were:
- Jennifer Cardy, aged 9, taken on 12 August 1981 while cycling to a friend's house in Ballinderry, County Antrim. Her body was found six days later in water at McKee's Dam, near Hillsborough.
- Susan Maxwell, aged 11, abducted on 30 July 1982 while walking home from playing tennis near Cornhill-on-Tweed, Northumberland. Her body was found in Staffordshire, a long way south of where she was taken.
- Caroline Hogg, aged 5, taken from outside a shop in Portobello, Edinburgh, on 8 July 1983. Her body was found in Leicestershire.
- Sarah Harper, aged 10, who disappeared in Morley, Leeds, on 26 March 1986. Her body was recovered from the River Trent.
The pattern of abduction in one area and discovery of the body hundreds of miles away made the crimes hard to connect, and it complicated the early inquiries.
Arrest in July 1990
Black was arrested on 14 July 1990 near Stow, in the Scottish Borders. A witness saw a young girl being taken, and police stopped his van. The girl, who was 6, was found alive inside. Black was convicted in Scotland of kidnap and sexual assault in connection with this incident.
The arrest prompted detectives to examine his earlier movements. His employer's records proved decisive. Investigators obtained fuel purchase slips from oil companies that supplied the firm's drivers, and officers searched them for his signature. They found that he had bought fuel close to the abduction sites at times near each disappearance. By the end of 1990 the inquiry team believed it had enough circumstantial evidence to put to prosecutors.
The 1994 trial at Newcastle Crown Court
The trial began on 13 April 1994 and lasted about five weeks. The prosecution relied on the cumulative weight of the evidence: his work routes, the fuel receipts, witness accounts and similarities between the offences. Black was found guilty on 19 May 1994 of the kidnap, rape and murder of Susan Maxwell, Caroline Hogg and Sarah Harper. He was also convicted of the attempted abduction of a 15-year-old girl in Nottingham in 1988.
He was sentenced to life imprisonment, with a recommendation that he serve at least 35 years. In English law a life sentence has no fixed end, and the minimum term, or tariff, is the period that must pass before a parole board can consider release.
The Jennifer Cardy trial in 2011
Police in Northern Ireland questioned Black about the death of Jennifer Cardy in 2005, and he was formally charged in December 2009. His trial opened at Armagh Crown Court in September 2011 before Judge Ronald Weatherup. He pleaded not guilty. The prosecution again used fuel receipts and delivery records to argue that he was in Northern Ireland at the relevant time, and it called a forensic pathologist, who described similarities with the death of Sarah Harper.
The jury heard about his previous convictions, which is unusual in a criminal trial and is permitted only in limited circumstances. After about four hours of deliberation, jurors found him guilty on 27 October 2011 of abduction, sexual assault and murder. On 8 December 2011 the judge set a minimum term of 25 years. Black appealed, and the Court of Appeal in Northern Ireland dismissed the appeal in 2013.
Unsolved cases and his death
Police suspected that Black might have been responsible for other crimes, and officers looked at a number of unsolved child disappearances and killings in Britain, Ireland and continental Europe between 1969 and 1987. At the time of his death he was regarded as the prime suspect in the 1978 disappearance of 13-year-old Genette Tate in Devon. No charge was ever brought in that case, and the other cases remain unproven against him.
Black died of a heart attack at HMP Maghaberry in Northern Ireland on 12 January 2016. Authorities did not treat the death as suspicious.
Why the case still matters
The case is often cited in discussion of how police forces share information. Crimes that crossed force boundaries were initially investigated separately, and it was only through cross-referencing records, and the painstaking search of fuel receipts, that detectives established where Black had been. His convictions came 13 years apart, and the last was secured three decades after the murder it concerned. For the families of the girls, and for those still seeking answers about unsolved cases, the legacy is one of long-delayed justice and unanswered questions.

