VerdictWorld.com
Witness protection in court: screens, video links and anonymity

Witness protection in court: screens, video links and anonymity

By LifespanSoftware · November 18, 2026

Criminal courts depend on witnesses who are willing to speak, yet some are frightened, vulnerable or at risk of reprisals. To address this, courts in many countries can adapt how evidence is given. The adaptations range from a simple screen in the courtroom to a full order that conceals a witness's identity. Each one has to be weighed against the defendant's right to a fair trial and the principle that justice is done in public.

Why courts adapt the way evidence is given

A trial is meant to test evidence face to face. Even so, a witness who fears the defendant, or who is young, traumatised or intimidated, may be unable to give a clear account in an ordinary courtroom. Courts therefore use protective measures to help people give their best evidence. The aim is to improve the quality of testimony, not to favour either side.

It helps to separate two ideas that are often confused. Practical help in the courtroom, such as screens or a video link, leaves the witness's identity known to the defence. Witness anonymity goes further and withholds who the witness is. Courts treat the second as far more serious.

Courtroom screens

Courtroom screens are the simplest measure. A physical screen stops the witness and the defendant seeing each other while the witness gives evidence. In England and Wales, the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999 lists screens among the special measures available to vulnerable and intimidated witnesses. The judge, jury and lawyers can normally still see the witness, so the court can assess the evidence in the usual way.

Other special measures under the same Act include:

  • giving evidence in private, with the public excluded in limited circumstances;
  • removing wigs and gowns;
  • playing a video-recorded interview as the witness's main evidence;
  • using an intermediary to help the witness communicate.

Video link testimony

Video link testimony lets a witness give evidence from another room in the court building or from a different location. Witnesses may sit in a separate room with a supporter beside them, and the courtroom sees and hears them on screen. Video links are also used for witnesses who live abroad or who cannot travel for medical reasons.

The defendant and jury can see and hear the witness, and the witness can be cross-examined as normal. Judges usually direct juries not to read anything into the use of a link. Courts take care over the technical quality, because a poor connection can undermine both the witness and the fairness of the process.

The position in the United States

In the United States, the Sixth Amendment gives defendants the right to confront witnesses. In Coy v Iowa (1988), the Supreme Court found a violation when a screen was used for child witnesses without a case-specific reason. In Maryland v Craig (1990), it accepted one-way closed-circuit television for a child witness, provided the trial court found that the child would suffer serious distress from testifying in front of the defendant. Both rulings show that protection needs a reasoned basis rather than a general assumption.

Witness anonymity

Witness anonymity is the most far-reaching option, and in England and Wales it is governed by statute. In R v Davis (2008), the House of Lords held that a conviction based solely or decisively on evidence from anonymous witnesses conflicted with the common law right to confront accusers. Parliament responded with emergency legislation, later replaced by Chapter 2 of Part 3 of the Coroners and Justice Act 2009.

Under that Act, a witness anonymity order may cover measures such as withholding the witness's name, using a pseudonym, screening the witness, altering their voice or barring questions that could reveal who they are. A court may make an order only if three conditions are met:

  1. the order is necessary to protect the safety of the witness or another person, to prevent serious damage to property, or to prevent real harm to the public interest;
  2. the order is consistent with the defendant receiving a fair trial;
  3. the witness's evidence is important enough that the witness ought to testify, and the witness would not do so without the order.

The court must also consider whether the witness could be protected by other means. Prosecution guidance describes such applications as a measure of last resort. If the case is heard by a jury, the judge must warn jurors that the order should not prejudice the defendant.

Balancing the defendant's rights

Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights guarantees a fair trial, including the right to examine witnesses. The European Court of Human Rights has accepted that there can be good reasons to limit confrontation, but it expects strong counterbalancing safeguards, particularly where the evidence is central to the case. Courts commonly allow the defence to put questions through the judge or through counsel, and they scrutinise the reliability of the evidence closely. Orders can be varied or discharged if circumstances change.

What this means for reporters

Protective measures often come with reporting restrictions. A court may order that a witness's name or identifying details must not be published, and breaching such an order can be punished as contempt of court. Separate rules in England and Wales give lifelong anonymity to complainants in sexual offence cases.

Journalists should therefore check the terms of any order before publishing. Screens and video links do not in themselves ban reporting of the evidence, but the court may restrict identifying details, and the restriction can apply to the courtroom, to written reports and to social media. Reporters should rely on what is said in open court and on the wording of the order itself.

Conclusion

Witness protection in court is a matter of proportion. Screens and video links are widely used to help people give evidence. Anonymity is rare and tightly controlled, because it departs furthest from the idea that an accused person can see and challenge the case against them. Understanding the difference helps readers, and reporters in particular, follow what a court has ordered and why.