Willie Cory Godbolt: the 2017 Mississippi shootings and trial
Willie Cory Godbolt was sentenced to death by a jury in Mississippi on 27 February 2020 after being convicted of eight killings committed on 27 May 2017 in Lincoln County. The sentences were handed down at the Pike County Courthouse in Magnolia. The Mississippi Supreme Court has upheld his convictions and sentences on direct appeal. A later petition for post-conviction relief was reported to be before that court. This article sets out what happened, what the jury decided and where the case stands.
The events of 27 May 2017
The shootings took place over the Memorial Day weekend. Godbolt had left his two children at his wife's mother's house in Bogue Chitto for a family barbecue. Later that evening he told his wife by text that he was coming to collect them. She replied that she intended to leave him and that she would call the police if he came to the house. Godbolt went anyway, and a 911 call was made asking for him to be removed.
Lincoln County Deputy William Durr attended and asked Godbolt to leave. At about 11:30 p.m., after the second request, Godbolt opened fire inside the house. Deputy Durr was killed, as were Godbolt's mother-in-law, Barbara Mitchell, and two other members of the family, Brenda May and Toccara May. Godbolt's wife escaped through a bedroom window with the children.
A second deputy who arrived was fired on and returned fire. Officers then surrounded the house, apparently unaware that Godbolt had already fled into the woods. After midnight he forced a woman to drive him away from the area. He was later arrested a considerable distance from where the first killings took place. He had been wounded in the arm during a confrontation with a homeowner.
Eight people were killed in all, across more than one location. It remains the deadliest mass shooting by a lone gunman in Mississippi's history.
The charges
Godbolt was charged with 12 counts. They were:
- four counts of capital murder;
- four counts of murder;
- two counts of kidnapping;
- one count of armed robbery; and
- one count of attempted murder.
In Mississippi, capital murder is the category of killing that can be punished by death. Examples include the killing of a police officer on duty or a killing committed during another serious crime. Ordinary murder carries a mandatory life sentence. For a death sentence, jurors must agree unanimously that it is the right punishment.
Verdict and sentencing in 2020
Convictions
Jurors convicted Godbolt on all 12 counts on Tuesday 25 February 2020. The four capital murder convictions related to Deputy Durr, Jordan Blackwell, Austin Edwards and Sheila Burage. The four murder convictions related to Brenda May, Barbara Mitchell, Toccara May and Feral Burage.
The penalty phase
The same jury then heard a separate sentencing hearing. Relatives of victims gave evidence, including the widow of Deputy Durr and the mother of a teenager who was killed. Godbolt also spoke. He said he had prayed to be a better man and attributed his actions to the devil. On Thursday 27 February the jury returned unanimous death sentences on each capital murder count. He received life imprisonment for each murder count and further sentences on the kidnapping, armed robbery and attempted murder counts.
The appeal to the Mississippi Supreme Court
Godbolt filed notice of appeal in August 2020. Death penalty appeals in Mississippi go straight to the state Supreme Court, which applies closer scrutiny to them than to other cases. His arguments included the following:
- that he should not have been tried on so many counts together and that the charges should have been severed;
- that he was denied an impartial jury, with his filing saying that four of the 12 jurors had links to law enforcement;
- that lawyers were unduly restricted when questioning potential jurors about the death penalty;
- that victim impact evidence and the instructions given to jurors were improper; and
- that his lawyers had given ineffective assistance and that the death sentences were unconstitutional.
Oral argument took place in November 2023. A request by Godbolt to argue his own case in person was refused. In March 2024 the court affirmed all the convictions and sentences. It held that the evidence supported the verdicts and the death sentences, that the trial court had properly admitted the evidence challenged, and that his trial counsel had not been ineffective. Godbolt's request for a rehearing was rejected in May 2024.
Later challenges
Godbolt then filed a handwritten petition asking the United States Supreme Court to review the state court's decision. That court declined to take the case. It did not give reasons, which is its usual practice when it refuses review.
On 21 April 2026 the Mississippi Supreme Court received a petition for post-conviction relief. This is a separate route that allows a prisoner to raise issues not dealt with at trial or on direct appeal. His lawyers argue that he has an intellectual disability, which under United States Supreme Court precedent would bar his execution. They say this was never investigated by his trial or appeal lawyers or put to the trial court for a final decision. They also allege that earlier counsel were ineffective. The petition asks the court to reverse the convictions and death sentences or to order an evidentiary hearing. These are claims made by the defence. The court had not ruled on them at the time of the latest reports.
Where the case stands
Godbolt is held on death row at the Mississippi State Penitentiary at Parchman. No execution date has been set. His direct appeals have ended, and the outcome of the post-conviction petition will decide whether any further court review follows.

