Open justice and its limits: how reporting restrictions work
Open justice is a founding principle of the courts in England and Wales and in many other countries: hearings take place in public, and the press may tell the public what it has seen and heard. Reporting restrictions are the carefully defined exceptions. They do not close the court, but they limit what can be published about a case, for how long, or about whom.
Why courts restrict publication
A judge or magistrate will usually act for one of a small number of reasons. The most common is to protect the right to a fair trial, so that jurors are not influenced by material heard outside the courtroom. Others are to protect children and vulnerable people, to safeguard the identity of those who would otherwise be at risk, and to avoid harm to related proceedings that have not yet been heard.
Restrictions are meant to be necessary and no wider than the problem requires. The European Convention on Human Rights, which informs the approach of courts in the United Kingdom, sets the right to respect for private life in Article 8 against freedom of expression in Article 10. A court asked to limit reporting must weigh the two, and press freedom is not set aside lightly.
Restrictions that apply automatically
Some limits arise by operation of law and need no order from a judge.
- Complainants in sexual offence cases. Under the Sexual Offences (Amendment) Act 1992, anyone who alleges a sexual offence is entitled to lifelong anonymity, and nothing may be published that could identify them.
- Children in youth courts. Reports of youth court proceedings generally may not identify the children involved, although a court can lift this in specific circumstances.
- The strict liability rule. Under the Contempt of Court Act 1981, publishing material that creates a substantial risk of serious prejudice to active proceedings can be a contempt of court, whatever the publisher intended.
The 1981 Act also protects a fair, accurate and contemporaneous report of proceedings held in public, published in good faith. This is why careful court reporting can safely describe what was said in open court, even when the details are uncomfortable.
Restrictions ordered by a judge
Postponement orders
Under section 4(2) of the 1981 Act, a court can order that a report of proceedings, or part of them, be delayed. This is typically used where one trial might prejudice another, for example when defendants are tried separately and publicity about the first could influence the second jury. The order delays publication; it does not ban it permanently.
Anonymity orders
Section 11 of the same Act allows a court that has lawfully withheld a name or other matter from the public to direct that it must not be published. Other statutes allow anonymity orders for children involved as defendants, victims or witnesses, and for certain adult witnesses where fear or distress would damage the quality of their evidence. These are separate from the measures used inside the courtroom, such as screens, and concern only what may be published outside it.
Anonymity for a defendant is unusual, because naming those charged is part of open justice. Where a court does grant protection, it generally needs a clear and specific justification.
Orders in other courts
Family proceedings carry their own restrictions, designed to protect children and family privacy, and the rules differ from those for criminal trials. Journalists should check what applies in each court before reporting.
Contempt of court and its consequences
Breaching a reporting restriction, or publishing material that risks prejudicing a trial, can amount to contempt of court. In England and Wales the Attorney General can bring proceedings for contempt, and a court may impose a fine or a prison sentence of up to two years. Individuals, publishers and online commentators can all be liable, which has become a practical concern as social media has widened who counts as a publisher.
Contempt law is not confined to the press. Jurors who research a case online, or witnesses who discuss evidence publicly, may also face action. The aim is to protect the integrity of the process, not to punish reporting as such.
How the press and courts work together
The relationship between the press and courts is more cooperative than adversarial. Courts are expected to tell the public when an order has been made, and journalists may attend to argue against a proposed restriction. A judge who hears from the media is better placed to decide whether a restriction is justified, and whether a narrower one would do.
Reporters in turn follow a routine: check for orders before filing, report only what has been said in open court, and use the words alleged or charged with until a conviction. Court staff and press officers can often confirm whether an order is in force.
A comparison with the United States
The US approach differs because of the First Amendment. In Nebraska Press Association v Stuart, decided in 1976, the Supreme Court held that an order preventing the press from reporting on a criminal case was an unjustified prior restraint. American judges instead rely on other tools to protect a fair trial, including careful questioning of potential jurors, moving a trial, and orders restricting what lawyers and parties may say, often called gag orders.
Why the rules matter
Reporting restrictions sit where two public interests meet: the public's right to know what happens in its courts, and the individual's right to a fair hearing and to protection from harm. Well-drafted orders are narrow, reasoned and open to challenge. Readers who understand why a name is missing or a report is delayed are better placed to judge whether the system is getting that balance right.

