VerdictWorld.com
Criminal Cases Review Commission: how convictions are reopened

Criminal Cases Review Commission: how convictions are reopened

By LifespanSoftware · November 20, 2026

When a conviction has been upheld on appeal, the courts have usually had their final say. The Criminal Cases Review Commission, known as the CCRC, exists for the rare cases where that may not be the end. It is an independent public body that investigates possible wrongful convictions and unfair sentences, and it can send a case back to an appeal court. It cannot overturn a conviction itself.

What the CCRC is and what it covers

The CCRC was set up under the Criminal Appeal Act 1995 and began work in 1997. It covers England, Wales and Northern Ireland. Scotland has its own separate body. The Commission is independent of the police, the prosecution, the courts and the government, and it is based in Birmingham.

Anyone who believes they have been wrongly convicted or wrongly sentenced can apply, and applying costs nothing. Relatives or representatives can apply on a person's behalf in some circumstances. Applicants do not need a lawyer, although many have one.

Who can apply, and when

The CCRC does not replace the ordinary appeal system. In most cases an applicant must already have appealed and lost, or been refused permission to appeal. Only in exceptional circumstances will the Commission look at a case that has not been through that process.

The Commission can review convictions and sentences from the Crown Court and from magistrates' courts. It can also look at sentencing problems, including cases where a sentence was wrongly calculated. In recent years it has referred a number of indeterminate sentences for public protection to the Court of Appeal.

The test for a case referral

The law sets a demanding threshold. A case referral can be made only if the Commission considers there is a real possibility that the appeal court would not uphold the conviction or sentence. That judgment normally depends on one of two things:

  • New evidence or a new argument that was not raised at trial or on appeal. Examples include fresh forensic findings, a retracted statement, or a legal point that was missed.
  • Exceptional circumstances, which allow the Commission to refer a case even where no new material has emerged.

The test asks whether the court might reach a different view. It is not a finding that the person is innocent, and it is not an opinion on guilt. The Commission is judging the prospects of a successful appeal.

How a review works

Initial assessment

Once an application arrives, the case is allocated to a case review manager. Many applications fail at an early stage because they raise no new point or concern matters the courts have already decided. Others move to a full review.

Investigation powers

The CCRC has statutory powers that an ordinary applicant lacks. It can require public bodies to hand over documents and material, and it can ask for fresh forensic testing or expert opinion. It can also arrange for police officers from another force to carry out inquiries. Often this is how a miscarriage of justice comes to light, when records that were never seen at trial are finally examined.

The decision

Decisions on referral are made by Commissioners, not by the case worker alone. The Commission sends a provisional statement of reasons to the applicant before it makes a final decision not to refer. The applicant can then respond and put forward more material. A decision not to refer can be challenged only by judicial review in the High Court, and the courts have been reluctant to interfere with the Commission's judgement.

What happens after a referral

A conviction from the Crown Court is sent to the Court of Appeal. In Northern Ireland the appeal goes to the Court of Appeal there. A conviction from a magistrates' court is sent to the Crown Court. The appeal is then heard on its merits, and a referral does not guarantee success.

Appeal judges can quash the conviction, uphold it, or alter the sentence. If a conviction is quashed, prosecutors may sometimes seek a retrial, which is a fresh trial before a new jury. In other cases the conviction is simply set aside and the person is free of it. Quashing a conviction can also open the way to a claim for compensation, though the statutory scheme is tightly drawn.

The numbers

The scale of the work is large, but referrals are few. The Commission's annual report for 2025 to 2026 recorded 1,841 applications, the highest figure it has received. It referred 45 cases to the appeal courts in the same year, up from 31 the year before. Since 1997 it has sent more than 900 cases back to the courts.

Most referred cases do succeed, though the proportion varies from year to year. An independent inspection in 2026 noted that quash rates were above 89% in 2021–22 and 2022–23. It put the figure for 2025–26 at 77.8% on the data then available.

Scrutiny and limits

The Commission has long faced criticism from campaigners who say it sets the bar too high, and from others who note that it works with limited resources. A 2026 inspection and an independent review of earlier casework both examined how the body operates. The CCRC has said it will carry out a change programme in response. The annual report also acknowledges the pressure that record demand places on the organisation and on its longest-running cases.

Why it matters

The appeal courts treat finality as important, and a conviction is not lightly reopened. The CCRC gives a route for the small number of cases where fresh evidence or a legal error casts real doubt on a verdict. For anyone considering an application, the main points are that the Commission looks for something new, that it can investigate in ways an individual cannot, and that the final decision on any conviction remains with the appeal court.